After much debate, and seeing her, I think Paisley is perfect for our little girl. It's feminine, unique, and the alliteration with our last name is adorable. The only tricky part is retraining Jane to say "Baby Paisley" instead of "Baby Olive". As many of you know, that was the name for a long time.
Her middle name, Kay, is after my Grandma Kay, who I had (have) a special bond with, love and miss.